Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
New Layout of Datasheet
#1
Thumbs Up 
Please give your comments on the following topics:

1) reference to the latest issue of the standard (2021)
2) addition of a marker if QSmax is a result of the load capability of the test equipment 
3) addition of a marker if bore intrusion occured during a specific test (requirement of EN 13555:2021)
4) footnote for 2) and 3)
5) addition of "<" if Qmin(L) or QSmin(L) is below the lowest applied gasket stress (no affect on the values in the database)
6) change/deletion of watermark (we received several comments on this topic: brighter, behind diagram, delete watermark, ...)

7) your additional suggestions


Attached Files
.pdf   Datasheet Layout Rev_3_0.pdf (Size: 351.83 KB / Downloads: 3)
Reply
#2
great improvements , I've no comment or objetions
Reply
#3
I agree with all changes. I suggest to delete the watermark.
Reply
#4
I have a concern about point 5.
If Qsmin will be changed from 10 MPa to <10 MPa, this means that a surface pressure of 1 MPa is sufficient to achieve the selected tightness class. We know that this is not true.
We already deleted values of Qsmin at 5 MPa from the published data because the results showed that blowout appears or will appear soon.
I think the manufacturers have in mind what the lowest possible surface pressure on the gasket could be to ensure operational safety, and this is also taken into account in the published data.
If the safety factor is taken into account the minimum gasket stress for 20 bar internal pressure would be 4 MPa. I dont see any problem If Qsmin values are measured at 5 MPa. So we are on the safe side.
Similar is for internal pressure of 40 bar. Minimum gasket stress should be 8 MPa. But I would be fine if the Qsmin values are measured at 10 MPa.
I would rather be on safe side and drop the < sign.

BR, Maja
Reply
#5
We agree with the changes
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)