Poll: Do you agree on publishing the data?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes
37.50%
3 37.50%
No (Comment in the thread)
0%
0 0%
Yes, but cross-check is required (Specify kind of test in the thread)
50.00%
4 50.00%
Abstain
12.50%
1 12.50%
Total 8 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
IDT Corrugated metallic gasket with graphite layer, WD10, WS1.4571/3803 3 mm
#1
Thumbs Up 
Approval of Data Import from gasketdata.org

Type: corrugated flat or grooved metallic and filled metallic gaskets
Publication: 18.06.2012

Material:GR

Link to gasketdata.org


Attached Files
.pdf   IDT_WD10 WS 1.4571-WS 3803 LE-3,0 mm_ESA Approval_2020-07-27.pdf (Size: 149.53 KB / Downloads: 15)
Reply
#2
E-Modulus looks weird but have too little experience for this gasket type to decide and will abstain.
Reply
#3
PQR values 500°C / 10 and 20 MPa  much higher compared to PQR 400°C ;  

crosscheck PQR 500°C and 20 MPa is required
Reply
#4
at 40bar and 40MPa tightness is 1.09E-05
at 25bar and 40MPa tightness is 1.08E-04
the higher the internal pressure the tighter the gasket?
I may proposse a x-check @ 40 bar
Reply
#5
(07-28-2020, 11:10 AM)Teadit Wrote: E-Modulus looks weird but have too little experience for this gasket type to decide and will abstain.
In the first test at 100°C there is a pick at 140 MPa. Based on my experience this is not an expected phenomenon. ¸I assume the reason is in the measurement. In such a case I would repeat the test, but this is a decision of the manufacturer.

(08-05-2020, 12:28 PM)Frenzelit Wrote: PQR values 500°C / 10 and 20 MPa  much higher compared to PQR 400°C ;  

crosscheck PQR 500°C and 20 MPa is required
The test results at 500°C look as they were performed later on other set of gaskets.
Agree with proposed crosscheck.

(08-05-2020, 05:40 PM)Klinger Wrote: at 40bar and 40MPa tightness is 1.09E-05
at 25bar and 40MPa tightness is 1.08E-04
the higher the internal pressure the tighter the gasket?
I may proposse a x-check @ 40 bar
Agree.
Reply
#6
Looking the Leak Rates at 80 bar:
At 80MPa/80bar for the first test the result is 1,15E-05
On the second test the result is 8,54E-06 (???)

At 100MPa/80bar first test shows 8,69E-06
Second one 1,09E-05

I believe that those are swapped, so perhaps a cross check is really necessary, or at least a good review on all submitted table data.
Perhaps a x-check will be easier and more reliable
Reply
#7
Cross-check was requested for tests at 500 °C. Also test result of the leakage test at 25 bar (which was not published on gasketdata.org) fits not to the results at 40 bar.

IDT was contacted and they decided that only the characteristics which were published on gasketdata.org should be transferred to the ESA database. This means that the values @ 500 °C and the leak rates @ 25 bar are not considered.
Reply
#8
I suggest to omit the Eg value of the first test at 140 MPa and 100°C as it is possible according to prEN13555:2019.
This value is not logical.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)